NFL Draft – Why Teams Should Avoid WR in Round One

Round one of the 2019 NFL Draft takes place on Thursday April 25. In the first 32 picks, how many teams will take a wide receiver? Is that really the best use of a first round draft pick?

History suggests that drafting a WR in the first round may not be the wisest decision. It certainly suggests that any form of success is far from guaranteed.

Proving the theory:

  • Over the past decade, only four teams have won a Super Bowl with a WR that they drafted in the first round on their roster (Nelson Agholor on 2017 Eagles, Demaryius Thomas on 2015 Broncos, Hakeem Nicks on 2011 Giants, Robert Meachem on 2009 Saints)
  • None of these WRs were taken in round 1 – Antonio Brown, Michael Thomas, Adam Thielen, Keenan Allen, Doug Baldwin, Tyreek Hill
  • These guys were all top 10 picks – John Ross, Justin Blackmon, Kevin White, Darrius Heyward-Bey, Tavon Austin, Sammy Watkins
  • Patriots have won 3 Super Bowls in the last decade (and been to 4) and have not drafted a WR in the first round over that time. The only first round WR that contributed to a Super Bowl winning team was Cordarrelle Patterson in 2019.

Now, let’s get even deeper into proving this idea that drafting a WR in the first round would be a mistake. Here’s a look at each first round WR class of the past decade.

2018

First round – DJ Moore (24), Calvin Ridley (26)
Non-first round picks – Dante Pettis (44), Christian Kirk (47), Anthony Miller (51)

Sample size is way too small after one year, but both first rounders were productive in 2018 and look to have potential heading into year two.

2017

First round – Corey Davis (5), Mike Williams (7), John Ross (9)
Non-first round – Juju Smith Schuster (62), Cooper Kupp (69), Chris Godwin (84), Kenny Golladay (96), Dede Westbrook (110)

The three first round picks have combined for 2,235 yards in two seasons. Juju Smith-Schuster, drafted at the end of round two, has 2,343 yards on his own.

2016

First round – Corey Coleman (15), Will Fuller (21), Josh Doctson (22), Laquon Treadwell (23)
Non-first round – Sterling Shepard (40), Michael Thomas (47), Tyreek Hill (165)

Michael Thomas is one of the 2 or 3 best WRs in football. Tyreek Hill is a serious threat to score a touchdown on every catch.

2015

First round – Amari Cooper (4), Kevin White (7), DeVante Parker (14), Nelson Agholor (20), Breshad Perriman (26), Phillip Dorsett (29)
Non-first round – Tyler Lockett (69), Jamison Crowder (105), Stefon Diggs (146)

Amari Cooper is a very good WR. Nelson Agholor has been reliable and solid, not a #1 option, but a dependable role player. Everyone else on this list stinks. Quite simply, none have lived up to the hype. I would take Lockett, Crowder, Diggs over any WR not named Cooper (and Diggs vs Cooper would be debatable).

2014

First round – Sammy Watkins (4), Mike Evans (7), Odell Beckham Jr (12), Brandin Cooks (20), Kelvin Benjamin (28)
Non-first round – Marquise Lee (39), Davante Adams (53), Allen Robinson (61), Jarvis Landry (63), John Brown (91), Quincy Enunwa (209)

This draft is both and exception and proof. Evans and Beckham are superstars and Cooks is very good. However Adams, Robinson, Landry, Brown, Enunwa have all been considered #1 WRs for their respective teams at one point, or another.

2013

First round – Tavon Austin (8), DeAndre Hopkins (27), Cordarrelle Patterson (29)
Non-first round – Robert Woods (41), Keenan Allen (76), Marquise Goodwin (78), Kenny Stills (144), Adam Thielen (UDFA)

26 teams passed on Hopkins, one of the best WRs in football. Austin and Patterson have been used as gadget players and sometimes even as running backs. Woods, Allen, Goodwin, Thielen were all #1 WRs in 2018.

2012

First round – Justin Blackmon (5), Michael Floyd (13), Kendall Wright (20), AJ Jenkins (30)
Non-first round – Alshon Jeffery (45), TY Hilton (92), Travis Benjamin (100), Marvin Jones (166)

There’s not much to say in defense of these first rounders, while the notably non-first round WRs are all still having a large impact on their respective teams.

2011

First round – AJ Green (4), Julio Jones (8), Jonathan Baldwin (26)
Non-first round – Torrey Smith (58) Randall Cobb (64)

Like 2014, this draft is an exception as Green and Jones are among the best WRs in football. But Smith and Cobb have long been reliable and Baldwin was a mega-bust at the end of the first round.

2010

First round – Demaryius Thomas (22), Dez Bryant (24)
Non-first round – Golden Tate (60), Emmanuel Sanders (82), Antonio Brown (195)

Bryant and Thomas were both great WRs for a while, but Bryant has fallen off a cliff and may never play again, after being released by the Cowboys last off-season and Thomas is recovering from a major injury. Sanders essentially supplanted Thomas in Denver, Brown has long been considered the best WR in football and Tate has always been a very solid contributor.

2009

First round – Darrius Heyward-Bey (7), Michael Crabtree (10), Jeremy Maclin (19), Percy Harvin (22), Hakeem Nicks (29), Kenny Britt (30)
Non-first round – Mike Wallace (84), Julian Edelman (232)

Edelman, the 232nd pick, won Super Bowl XLIII MVP. If that isn’t enough proof….


More MIKEDROPSPORTS NFL Draft Articles

For more NFL talk, you can follow me on twitter @msschneid or instagram @mikedropsports 

About Mike Schneid 540 Articles
Mike is a member of the FWAA (Football Writers Association of America) and an alum of the University of Cincinnati.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*